Summary
We report on results from Work Package 4 of the ImpTail project (Improved submarine tailing placements in Norwegian fjords). The aim of this work was to test whether benthic animals with poor dispersal ability can be genetically differentiated among fjords and among deep basins within fjords. Such differentiation could impact on recolonization of fjord basins after tailing deposition terminates, and also on small isolated populations that depend on immigration to sustain their stocks in a longer term. We focused on three deep-water benthic invertebrates, which were expected to differ markedly in dispersal abilities. The squat lobster Munida sarsi remains benthic in the adult stage, releasing large numbers of free-swimming larvae, which live as zooplankton for several months. Thus, this species was expected ta have very good dispersal capability. In contrast, the mussel Astarte sulcata has very limited mobility. Their eggs are brooded within the mother’s shell, and are released as small but fully developed mussels without any swimming ability. The third species, another crustacean Diastyloides serratus is also a brooder lacking a free-living larval stage, and is only capable of a little swimming. Our expectation was that the two latter species had poor dispersal abilities. Genetic differentiation between populations was estimated by analyzing allelic variation in microsatellites, which is a type of genetic marker known as hypervariable due to high mutation rates. 10 such markers were developed for each species within the project. We collected animals from three basins in the Førdefjord (inner, middle and outer basins), and supplementary material from several other stations along the coast was also analyzed to extend the geographic coverage. In Munida sarsi, differentiation was very low, and not statistically different from zero, thus confirming our expectation of very god dispersal ability in this species. By contrast, we found low, but statistically significant genetic differentiation among fjords and fjord basins in the other two species. In the case of Astarte sulcata, we detected a marked differentiation between two stations separated by only 250 m. The results indicate that species with limited dispersal capabilities can be genetically differentiated among fjord basins, and dispersal between basins can thus be limited. Marginal populations in partly isolated basins can be dependent on immigration to remain viable in the long term. Deposition of mine tailings in a basin which functions as a source population for other basins could thus potentially affect regions beyond the deposition area itself. Such an effect is likely to depend on factors like habitat quality, population size and reproductive rates of different species. We suggest that it may be desirable to investigate whether fjord basins selected for tailing deposition may have such importance for adjacent fjord basins.